We’re not sure what makes Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Company so endearing. Is it the hilarious puns? The adorable cows that grace their packaging? Could it be their devotion to their home state of Vermont? Or is it their unyielding commitment to social justice and environmental issues? Whatever it is, Ben & Jerry’s has become a beloved and iconic American ice cream brand.

Ben & Jerry’s is renowned for creating brilliant and innovative ice cream flavors. No one else is so generous with their swirls and chunks of sweet additions. But what’s the best Ben & Jerry’s flavor? 

We at GoPuff are huge fans of Ben & Jerry’s, so we conducted a completely random and utterly unscientific survey to determine which are Ben & Jerry’s best ice cream flavors. Our conclusion? It’s impossible to decide. There’s no single best Ben & Jerry’s flavor or best Ben & Jerry's non-dairy flavor, for that matter. They’re all equally scrumptious, and everyone's favorite flavor is fit to be eaten directly from the carton.

We present GoPuff’s list of Ben & Jerry's top flavors we can’t live without. Pull up a scoop and prepare to indulge.

1. Ben & Jerry's Half Baked Ice Cream 16oz

Filled with chunks of fudge brownie and cookie dough, Ben & Jerry's Half Baked Ice Cream pint is a time-tested favorite among snack lovers of all persuasions. It's crafted in partnership with Greyston & Rhino Bakeries, a B Corp, and outfitted with sustainably sourced packaging so you can feel good about eating your feelings.

$6.49

2. Ben & Jerry's Netflix & Chill'd Ice Cream 16oz

Netflix & Chill’d is one of Ben & Jerry’s newest flavors, rapidly becoming a fan favorite. How can you not love creamy peanut butter ice cream mixed with sweet and salty pretzel swirls and delicious chunks of chocolate fudge brownies? There’s a flavor for everyone in this chillaxing new creation, and it’ll be sure to satisfy any sweet or salty snack craving. It’s a flavorful world, so grab a spoon.

$6.49

3. Ben & Jerry's The Tonight Dough Ice Cream 16oz

Curated with Tonight Show host Jimmy Fallon, Ben & Jerry's Tonight Dough has all the ingredients to cure those late-night cravings. This caramel and chocolate ice cream mix is filled to the brim with large chunks of peanut butter cookie dough and gooey chocolate cookie crumbles. Proceeds from the sale of this delicious pint support the SeriousFun Children's Network.

$6.49

4. Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy P.B. & Cookies Pint Frozen Dessert 16oz

Non-dairy vanilla ice cream. Chocolate cookie sandwich chunks. Crunchy peanut butter swirls. Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy P.B. Cookies Frozen Dessert is vegan, non-GMO, and Fair Trade Certified, which means it's totally OK to polish off the entire pint in one sitting. Seriously, can a frozen treat get any better than this? We think not.

$6.49

5. Ben & Jerry's The Americone Dream Ice Cream 16oz

Ben & Jerry's AmeriCone Dream Ice Cream is made from sweet vanilla ice cream, fudge-covered waffle cone pieces, and a luscious caramel swirl. Ben & Jerry’s churned up this delectable creation in honor of The Late Show host, Stephen Colbert. This flavor supports charitable causes through The Stephen Colbert AmeriCone Dream Fund. 

$6.49

6. Ben & Jerry's Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream 16oz

Ben & Jerry's Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream tastes exactly as expected: rich, creamy, and utterly irresistible. Sweet strawberry ice cream made with fresh, delicious berries is laced with a crispy graham cracker swirl, so you know there's no skimping on flavor. It's almost like the real thing — but frozen! And a lot less work. Get a pint today.

$6.49

7. Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia Ice Cream 16oz

This classic flavor from Ben & Jerry’s is still one of their best. Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia Ice Cream is made with real cherries and rich fudge flakes for a euphorically edible tribute to guitarist Jerry Garcia and Grateful Dead fans everywhere. This delectable cherry ice cream is the first named for a rock legend and the most famous of the fan-suggested flavors. Even better? It’s certified gluten-free.

$6.49

8. Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Coconut Seven Layer Bar Pint

If you’re looking to reach seventh heaven through a non-dairy dessert treat, Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Coconut Seven Layer Bar is your path. Made with a delicious almond milk base, this sweet indulgence combines coconut flakes, walnut chunks, chocolate fudge, and luscious swirls of graham crackers and butterscotch. It’s guaranteed to transport you to the next level of indulgent bliss.

$6.99

9. Ben & Jerry's Phish Food Ice Cream 16oz

This pint of chocolate ice cream has ooey-gooey caramel and marshmallow swirls with chocolate fudge fish. A Ben & Jerry's favorite, Phish Food Ice Cream is certified gluten-free and made with sustainably sourced, non-GMO, and fair trade ingredients — so you don't have to feel guilty about rocking out with a big bowl. Or two. 

$6.49

10. Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream 16oz

It’s your childhood favorite brought to life in ice cream form! Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream is the ultimate dessert for peanut butter lovers far and wide. Featuring peanut butter cups buried in decadent peanut butter ice cream, it's a simple snack, but it's like Da Vinci said: Sometimes, simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.

$6.49

11. Ben & Jerry's Topped Chocolate Caramel Cookie Dough Ice Cream 15.2oz

Have difficulty choosing between cookies and ice cream? We can’t blame you. On the one hand, you have sweet, chewy cookies; on the other, rich, luxurious ice cream. It’s a dilemma, but now you don’t have to decide. Chocolate ice cream mixes with decadent caramel swirls and chocolate chip cookie dough, then topped with a layer of chocolate ganache and caramel cups for a luxurious frozen delight.

$6.49

12. Ben & Jerry's Chubby Hubby Ice Cream 16oz

Get dad-bod sexy with this indulgent sweet treat. Ben & Jerry’s combines sweet vanilla malt ice cream with peanutty fudge-covered pretzels and swirls of chocolate fudge and peanut butter. All of your favorite snacks are blended into one ridiculously delicious ice cream. It’s best eaten when life has gotten just a bit too swirly.

$6.49

13. Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Change the Whirled Frozen Dessert 16oz

Ben & Jerry's Change the Whirled is made with caramel non-dairy frozen dessert combined with fudge chips, ribbons of graham cracker, and chocolate cookie swirls. Colin Kaepernick serves sweet justice with the non-dairiest compilation of cookies and caramel. This flavor honors Colin’s activism in pursuit of racial justice, and his portion of the proceeds from sales support the Know Your Rights Camp.

$6.49

FAQ

What are the best Ben & Jerry's flavors?

We have our favorites, and obviously, you do too. Here are a few more best-selling Ben & Jerry's flavors that continue to fly off the grocery store shelves. 

Chunky Monkey: Go bananas with Chunky Monkey. And by bananas, we mean banana ice cream blended with fudge chunks and walnuts for a toothsome treat.

Gimme S'More:A delicious combination of toasted marshmallow ice cream, chocolate cookie and graham cracker swirls, and fudge flakes that’ll have you singing Kumbaya in no time.

Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch: Wake up to delectable coffee ice cream combined with fudge-covered toffee bar pieces for an icy treat that’ll keep you buzzing. 

Chocolate Therapy: Attention, chocolate lovers! You may have met your match with a blend of chocolate ice cream swirled with chocolate cookies and dark chocolate pudding ice cream. But we doubt it.

Everything But The…: A collision of chocolate and vanilla ice cream, mixed with peanut butter cups, fudge-covered toffee, and almonds plus white chocolate fudge. Yes, please!

What is Ben & Jerry's least popular flavor?

Not all of Ben & Jerry’s ice cream flavors are home runs. Some of them are definitely a swing and a miss. Maybe we’re wrong; in someone’s opinion, these may be the best Ben & Jerry’s ice cream flavors. But if you decide to try them, don’t say we didn’t warn you.

Cinnamon Buns: Caramel ice cream combined with cinnamon bun dough? Ummm… we’re not sure, but maybe baked goods are best served beside our ice cream, not in it.

Pistachio Pistachio: We don’t get the appeal of nut-flavored ice cream, and we’re not sure we want one that might induce an allergy attack.

Brownie Batter Core: Yes, we love chocolate brownies. Yes, we love ice cream. But this sounds like a bit much, even for us.

What’s the weirdest Ben and Jerry's flavor?

Oh, there have been some weird ones over the years. Many have been retired, such as Fred and Ginger (1988), a combination of chocolate bow ties blended into ginger ice cream. There are still a few available, though. Some are even on Ben & Jerry’s Best Selling Flavor list.

Ben & Jerry's Pumpkin Cheesecake Pint: Pumpkin ice cream combined with graham cracker swirl? We get the feeling that we’re taking this Fall trend a little too far. 

Ben & Jerry's Topped Strawberry Topped Tart: We don’t know about you, but we firmly believe ice cream belongs on top of a piece of pie, not the pie in the ice cream.