Dear chocoholics and ice cream fanatics: You’ll want to bookmark this page for future reference. Ice cream is an incredibly popular snack with a creamy texture that many of us have indulged in since childhood. One of the most popular flavors is chocolate ice cream, standing the test of time and bringing an air of nostalgia with each bite.

Now, why would we want to list the best chocolate ice cream to buy? We want to give you plenty of options to satisfy your chocolate craving and provide you with the top choices for a pint of ice cream to cool you down on a hot day.

This list has something for everyone, from dark and robust to light and creamy, vegan, gluten-free, and nut-free — you can all indulge in this tried-and-true classic flavor, no matter your dietary needs.

If this classic flavor is your favorite or you need some ice cream inspo, here’s a list of the best chocolate ice cream you can buy. Warning: chocolate cravings may increase upon reading this list. 

1. Blue Bell Dutch Chocolate Ice Cream

Allergy warnings: Dairy

Blue Bell Chocolate is a delicious blend of skim milk, sugar, cream, and alkali-processed cocoa (sometimes called Dutch cocoa). It all comes together in a thick, delightful mix of chocolatey goodness. For one of the best store-bought ice cream options, this one is sure to please.

Shop now: Blue Bell Dutch Chocolate Ice Cream

2. Haagen-Dazs Chocolate Ice Cream

Allergy warnings: Dairy, eggs

Haagen-Dazs needs little introduction, so naturally, its chocolate flavor makes our list one of the best ice cream pints to buy. This super-sweet treat is perfect for all occasions. 

It’s rich, creamy, and totally indulgent. Made from the finest cocoa and pure, sweet cream, this chocolate ice cream is the ultimate experience.

Shop now: Haagen-Dazs Chocolate Ice Cream

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

3. Jeni’s Darkest Chocolate Ice Cream

Allergy warnings: Dairy

Why we love it: it’s founded by women. Mouth-filling and palate-gripping with a pleasingly dry finish. Packed with Fair Trade cocoa and not much else.

For the best dark chocolate ice cream, Jeni’s is a decadent option capturing the rich tones of a chocolate bar before adding the sweetness of tapioca syrup to give it a lighter flavor. The end result is an ice cream that passes the chocoholic taste test.

Shop now: Jeni’s Darkest Chocolate Ice Cream

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

4. Breyers Chocolate Ice Cream

Allergy warnings: Dairy

When it comes to chocolate ice cream brands, Breyers is a champ and the best budget option. Breyers Chocolate Ice Cream is made with non-GMO sourced ingredients like fresh cream, milk, and sugar — and it’s gluten-free. And that flavorful chocolate satisfying your taste buds? That’s real cocoa we use in every ice cream tub. It's the chocolate ice cream of your dreams, rich and creamy with just the right amount of sweetness.

Shop now:Breyers Chocolate Ice Cream

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

5. J.P. Licks Chocolate Ice Cream Pint

Allergy warnings: Dairy

J.P. Licks is an ice cream, yogurt, and coffee chain that launched in 1981, beginning with a single store in the Jamaica Plain neighborhood in Boston. Since then, it has grown to 16 locations, maintaining its sweet treat excellence. 

Out of their variety of flavors, the chocolate ice cream option is the classic, made with bittersweet Belgian chocolate as its main ingredient. 

Shop now: J.P. Licks Chocolate Ice Cream Pint

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

6. Bassetts Chocolate Ice Cream Pint

Allergy warnings: Dairy, soy

Bassetts is another well-known ice cream brand that launched in Philadelphia in 1861. With this stable reputation, you know the types of chocolate ice cream they offer will be stellar. 

One of their more popular choices is the classic chocolate pint with its rich Dutch cocoa base. 

Shop now: Bassetts Chocolate Ice Cream Pint

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

7. Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Therapy Ice Cream

Allergy warnings: Milk, wheat, eggs, soy

Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Therapy Ice Cream is a delicious mix of cream, sugar, skim milk, alkali-processed chocolate, brown sugar, and vanilla extract. Eat it when: you don't want to awkwardly run into your classmates in the waiting room of your psychiatrist's office.

Shop now: Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Therapy Ice Cream

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

8. Van Leeuwen Chocolate Fudge Brownie Ice Cream Pint

Allergy warnings: Dairy, eggs, wheat

Nothing makes us happier than this Chocolate Fudge Brownie Ice Cream. Now, are rich chocolate fudge and chewy chocolate brownies good for you? Probably not. But on the other hand, are rich chocolate fudge and chewy chocolate brownies good for you? Probably. That’s just science.

Van Leeuwen makes good ice cream that makes you feel good because a life without anything good is bad.

Only good ingredients you can pronounce.

Shop now:Van Leeuwen Chocolate Fudge Brownie Ice Cream Pint

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

9. Halo Top Chocolate Pint

Allergy warnings: Dairy, eggs 

A Halo Top Chocolate Pint a night keeps the doctor away. Can we really say anything more wonderful about Chocolate? Dive into this scrumptious Chocolate pint and see if you can believe it’s only 300 calories per pint and a good source of protein.

Shop now: Halo Top Chocolate Pint

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

10. Talenti Dairy-Free Sorbetto Dark Chocolate

Allergy warnings: Coconut

Dairy-free, gluten-free, Non-GMO Project Verified, this decadent dairy-free dark chocolate sorbetto perfectly pairs cocoa and a dairy-free chocolate sauce. It’ll taste just as good as traditional ice cream, and it’s perfect for anyone who struggles with gastrointestinal issues.

Shop now: Talenti Dairy-Free Sorbetto Dark Chocolate

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

11. Honeysuckle Gelato German Chocolate Cake Pint

Allergy warnings: Pecans, coconut

Contrary to popular belief, the German chocolate cake actually originated in Texas, and accordingly, this gelato has a big flavor. It’s a rich chocolatey base layered with toasted coconut caramel, chocolate cake bits, and roasted Georgia pecans — and it’s vegan.

Shop now: Honeysuckle Gelato German Chocolate Cake Pint

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

12. Craigs Dairy-Free Frozen Dessert Perfectly Chocolate

Allergy warnings: Cashews

Chocoholics rejoice! Our much-anticipated and long-requested flavor has arrived. It’s no coincidence it’s called Perfectly Chocolate. Each tub takes premium cashews and decadent chocolate, then churns it to perfection.

Shop now:Craigs Dairy-Free Frozen Dessert Perfectly Chocolate

Image pulled from Gopuff product page

FAQs

Which brand of chocolate ice cream is best?

This largely depends on personal preference — and if it were up to us, we would make this decision based on trial and error (read: keep trying different brands of chocolate ice cream until you find your favorite). We know that Haagen-Dazs Chocolate Ice Cream flies off the grocery store shelves and remains a consistent consumer favorite.

But the best brand for you will depend on the price, packaging, and your dietary preferences. Fortunately, most ice cream brands have curated their selections for all types of diets, including keto, vegan, free of egg yolks, gluten-free, and nut-free. 

The best brand of chocolate ice cream could also be impacted by the ice cream flavors they offer. Your taste could favor milk chocolate, for which plenty of ice cream brands will deliver. But then you have Ben & Jerry’s, which loves to liven up its recipes with ingredients like peanut butter, chocolate chips; whereas Breyers’ vanilla bean is a classic.

What is the creamiest chocolate ice cream?

When you indulge in chocolate ice cream, you crave creaminess and that melt-in-your-mouth feel. So which chocolate ice cream delivers? We’ll give Haagen-Dazs Chocolate Ice Cream props again for creating one of the richest, creamiest chocolate ice cream options on the market. 

A quick note: Traditional ice cream typically uses a heavier ratio of cream than milk, so for the creamiest options, seek out ice cream like Blue Bell, Bassetts, and Breyers, instead of non-dairy alternatives. 

What is the most popular ice cream brand in the world?

The most famous worldwide ice cream brands include Ben & Jerry’s and Haagen-Dazs. You’ll undoubtedly recognize their iconic packaging on the freezer shelves.

Want to browse through Gopuff’s full selection of frozen treats? Don’t forget to shop online to have those items delivered straight to your door.