If you’re like most, your day doesn’t start until you’ve consumed your first cup of coffee. It’s an essential morning ritual. Your first cup of joe helps ease you into the day’s routine, waking you up and putting your feet on the path to being a productive human being.

Given the importance of that first cuppa, you want it to be as rich and delicious as possible. Waking up to an unsatisfying cup of bean juice can throw off your morning, if not your entire day. Sure, you could go to a coffee shop, but that’s not always possible. That’s where plain and flavored coffee creamers come in.

Creamers are a quick and easy way to lighten and sweeten black coffee. You could use milk, but if you’re looking for a café experience, plain dairy products won’t deliver the same rich decadence of flavor options as a creamer. And for those avoiding dairy, there are many choices of plant-based possibilities, so you don’t give up any of the lavish taste. 

So, which are the best coffee creamers for your morning cup of java? Coffee drinkers, you can rest assured that our team left no stone unturned to put together a list of the best coffee creamer flavors to perk up your jitter juice and replace your half-and-half.By the way, can you let us know when the ground stops shaking? Thanks. 

1. Coffee mate Natural Bliss Sweet Cream 32oz

Best Classic Flavor Coffee Creamer

Natural Bliss delivers sweet, creamy, all-natural dairy flavor for a blissful cup of coffee. It’s made from farm-fresh milk and cream, pure cane sugar, and natural flavors, so nothing comes between you and your cup of joe. It’s simply the best creamer for coffee-flavored coffee lovers.

$7.69

2. Starbucks Hazelnut Oat Milk Creamer 28oz Btl

Best Non-Dairy Coffee Creamer

Enjoy your morning cup at home, dairy-free, with a creamer inspired by the Starbucks hazelnut flavor you crave. A delicious combination of oat and almond milk and the continental Italian flavor of hazelnuts, it’s the perfect way to say Ciao to your busy day.

$6.49

3. Coffee mate Natural Bliss Almond Milk Vanilla Creamer 16oz

Best Almond Milk Coffee Creamer

Kick-start your morning cuppa with an all-natural, cholesterol- and lactose-free, plant-based creamer. Enjoy this vegan coffee addition made with almond milk, pure cane sugar, and luxurious Madagascar vanilla. Life can’t get any sweeter.

$4.79

4. So Delicious Organic French Vanilla Coconut Creamer 32oz

Best Organic Non-Dairy Coffee Creamer

Take your coffee to new heights with So Delicious Dairy Free French Vanilla Creamer made with organic coconut milk. Using only seven plant-based, non-GMO ingredients, you’ll add a rich, velvety French vanilla goodness to your coffee, free of dairy and lactose. Plus it’s soy-free and gluten-free.

$6.59

5. Milkadamia Unsweetened Macadamia Creamer 16oz

Best Sugar-Free Coffee Creamer

This decadent, vegan coffee creamer is made from macadamia nuts and will add billowing clouds of sweet vanilla flavor to your favorite brew. So creamy and delicious, you would never know it’s a dairy-free creamer with no added sugar or artificial sweeteners. Experience euphoria in your cup.

$4.99

6. Starbucks Caramel Macchiato Creamer 28oz

Best Café Flavor Coffee Creamer

It’s the perfect solution for days when you can’t visit your favorite barista. Starbucks non-dairy Caramel Macchiato creamer makes brewing your favorite coffee easy. It's decadence in a bottle with sweet, buttery caramel combined with light vanilla flavor. You might never leave home again.

$6.49

7. Coffee mate Funfetti Coffee Creamer

Best Vanilla Flavored Coffee Creamer

Sometimes, you require a touch of whimsy to face the day ahead. Nestle Coffee Mate understands. That’s why they’ve created Funfetti Vanilla Cake Liquid Coffee Creamer. It’s the perfect way to transform your everyday coffee drinking experience into something to celebrate.

$5.49

8. Coffee mate Natural Bliss Brown Sugar Oat Milk Creamer 32oz

Best Oat Milk Coffee Creamer

Start your day off with some Natural Bliss in your coffee cup. This oat milk-based vegan creamer is a sweet way to warm up, thanks to the addition of natural cane sugar and a touch of maple syrup flavor. Enjoy the texture of heavy cream and sweet taste that’s free of gluten, wheat, and soy.

$6.99

9. Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Creamer 28oz Btl

Best Seasonal Coffee Creamer

Pour this creamer into your coffee, and you’ll be anything but basic. Inspired by Starbucks’ signature Pumpkin Spice Latte, Starbucks pumpkin spice flavored creamer makes every cup taste like the real thing. Enjoy your favorite seasonal flavor without waiting until Fall!

$6.99

10. Coffee mate French Vanilla Fat Free Creamer 32oz

Best Fat-Free Coffee Creamer

Add a rich and creamy french vanilla coffee creamer with none of the fat. It’s a non-dairy creamer free of lactose, gluten, and cholesterol. You’ll get the perfect amount of vanilla flavor to elevate a simple cup of coffee into a flavorful pick-me-up.

$5.49

FAQ

What’s the most popular coffee creamer?

There are a lot of different flavors of coffee creamer for you to choose from. If you’re unsure which one to try and you’re OK with following the pack, these are the most popular flavors of coffee creamers on the grocery store shelves in 2022.

French Vanilla Coffee Creamer: Thick, creamy texture and a rich vanilla flavor make Natural Bliss Almond Milk Vanilla Creamer our go-to for a sweet mid-afternoon pick-me-up.

Cafe Mocha Coffee Creamer: This is the ideal flavor when you can’t decide between hot chocolate and coffee. Starbucks White Chocolate Mocha Creamer is a lush flavor combination. 

Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer: When all you want is a touch of sweetness and fresh creamy flavor, Natural Bliss Sweet Cream is here to satisfy.

Hazelnut Coffee Creamer: Enjoy hazelnuts’ sweet, nutty flavor with your coffee. A sip of Starbucks Hazelnut Oat Milk Creamer will immediately transport you to the Piazza San Marco in Venice.

Caramel Macchiato Coffee Creamer: Bring authentic café flavor home with Starbucks’ delicious buttery Caramel Macchiato Creamer. 

What’s the healthiest creamer to put in coffee?

If you’re looking for a healthy coffee creamer, you’ll need to read the labels. Your primary concern is the amount of sugar per serving of creamer. Most commercial brands have between 5 and 6 grams of sugar per tablespoon. If you’re sticking to the guideline of 25 grams of sugar for every 1000 calories you eat, that number begins to add up.

In this case, the healthiest coffee creamers are the lower sugar and sugar-free varieties. If you don’t mind a little sugar in your coffee, we recommend So Delicious Organic French Vanilla Coconut Creamer. It has 3 grams of sugar per serving, about half the amount of most commercial brands, and it’s made with organic coconut cream, so it has a wonderfully rich texture. 

If you want to cut out sugar entirely, give Milkadamia Unsweetened Vanilla Macadamia Creamer a try. It’s free of sugar and artificial sweetener and made from macadamia nuts and coconut creme for a taste so decadent you won’t notice that you’re giving anything up.

The other ingredient to consider is carrageenan gum. Carrageenan takes the place of gelatin as a thickening agent in vegetarian and vegan-friendly food, such as ice cream, puddings, infant formulas, and coffee creamers. Most people can tolerate it with no problem, but you want to avoid this ingredient if you have any gastrointestinal issues. If you’re looking for a carrageenan-free creamer, both So Delicious and Milkadamia fit the bill, as does Natural Bliss Sweet Cream. 

If you have any concerns, please seek guidance from a registered dietitian. They’ll have all the answers you need.

What kind of creamer is best for you?

Your best coffee creamer depends on your dietary needs. If you have no nutritional concerns, pick the one you can’t wait to pour into your morning cuppa.

If you’re working on changing your lifestyle by following a particular dietary routine, there are coffee creamers that you can incorporate into your new meal plans.

The Best Coffee Creamer For Weight Loss: If you’re trying to slim down, the best additions to your coffee are low in sugar or sugar-free. Dairy and plant-based milk like soy or oat will better help you reach your goals than a commercial coffee creamer. If you find you’re missing the flavors, you can add some vanilla extract, cinnamon, or cocoa to your coffee to perk it up a bit.

The Best Keto Coffee Creamer:  Milkadamia Unsweetened Vanilla Macadamia Creamer is your best choice for a keto-friendly addition to your morning cup of joe. It has 0 grams of sugar, and 0 grams of total carbs, making it the perfect option for a keto diet.

The Best Coffee Creamer For Intermittent Fasting: If you’re looking for a coffee creamer to help you break your fast or mix with MCT oil in your bulletproof coffee, look no further than Coffee Mate Hazelnut Creamer. It has only 25 calories with 3 grams of sugar plus a rich flavor and a creamy texture you crave.

No matter your dietary plan, always consult with a registered dietitian for guidance and support to help you reach your health goals.